Skip to main content

Decide on VPC Network Traffic Isolation Policy

Context and Problem Statement​

Describe why we are making this decision or what problem we are solving.

Considered Options​

Both options support principles of least privilege.

Option 1 - Use a Flat Network with two Subnets per AZ (Public, Private) (Recommended)​

Our Recommendation is to use Option 1 because it is the easiest to administer and reduces the complexity of the

network architecture

Pros​

  • Use Security Group ACLs to easily restrict service-to-service communication using Security Group IDs.

  • Elastic network that doesn’t require advanced insights into the size and growth of the workloads

Cons​

  • Security Groups have limited flexibility across regions: e.g. Security Group ACLs only work with CIDRs across regions (and not by Security Group ID)

  • Harder to monitor traffic between workloads

Option 2 - Use a Custom Subnet Strategy Based on Workload​

Pros​

  • More easily restrict network traffic across regions and data centers

  • Follows principles of Least-privilege

  • Also compatible with using Security Group ACLs for an additional layer of security

  • Easier to monitor traffic between workloads

Cons​

  • Requires advanced planning to identify and allocate all workloads and IP space

  • Harder to scale elastically

  • Puts a large burden on network administrators

  • Large route tables, complicated transit gateway rules

  • Requires active monitoring to ensure subnets are not at capacity

References​